Before technology was cool . . . OK, maybe that is too far back for technology. How about before information technology (IT) was cool, there were manual processes of paper and people. The advent of the computer and the advances of telecommunications have allowed much to be accomplished . . . and not all of it is good.
Service organizations adopting technology did so in the name of automation and modernization. Why have paper when we can have information technology? Or, why have people when we can have information technology?
Salient questions that have created more hype than good sense in the answers to them. IT has become management’s monolith – huge structures that rival the pyramids for the modern day executive pharaohs.
However, the unquestioning embrace of IT as the “answer” to all things manual has led us to more bureaucracy and greater complexity. Neither being optimal for customers or those front-line staff that have to interact with them.
Why is this so?
Two major reasons are the design of the work was never optimal and in order to make IT work we have had to expand how to manage IT.
The design of the work into front- back and sometimes even middle offices goes unchallenged. This is more the mass-production and industrialized thinking of manufacturing . . . which, by the way, has not worked well since W. Edwards Deming visited Japan to show them a better way. The US now struggles to compete in manufacturing at all. Wrongly thinking that cheaper labor is the key and not the design of the work. Service has embraced this thinking of yesteryear to add costs and miss the point about the causes of costs.
The second reason for IT is the structures (monoliths) we have built to control IT costs. Yet, they drive costs up.
The explosion of IT has brought us the project manager and projects to keep costs under control. But no one questions the costs of project management. They do offer us ways to check up on those “always behind” developers and we all love those Red-Yellow-Green reports that tell us nothing associated with what is really going on.
Before project management, we had business analysts that in EDS were originally part of the path to become a software developer. Now, the BA position is an end in itself to make a production line mentality complete. BA gets the requirements and the developer codes. Besides good developers are costly and should be hidden away and they don’t know how to interact with business folks – ahhhhh, I knew there was a good reason.
Let us not forget about governance, good management of IT means good governance. We have to have standards, plans, priorities, reports, risk management, fiduciary responsibility, etc., etc., etc. And now one begins to wonder how it is IT is actually saving money?
Plus in many large organizations trying to get an improvement through IT or fix something is such that . . . a snowball would have a better chance in Hades.
Maybe it is time to rethink IT, what do you think?
Join me for the International Deming Conference in New York City on March 21 – 22.
Tripp Babbitt is a speaker, blogger and consultant to service industry (private and public). His organization helps executives find a better way to make the work work. Read his articles at Quality Digest and his column for CustomermanagementIQ.com Download free from www.newsystemsthinking.com “Understanding Your Organization as a System” and gain knowledge of systems thinking or contact us about our intervention services at [email protected]. Reach him on Twitter at www.twitter.com/TriBabbittor LinkedIn at www.linkedin.com/in/trippbabbitt.Share This:
I couldn’t agree more Tripp !
People at all levels in organisations still seem to be in awe of IT and its many flashing lights. It’s almost akin to a religion – with anyone who questions the use of IT as anything other than sensible and beneficial a heretic (and I say this as a Systems Architect, MCSE, and SAP architect with over 20 years experience).
The real value in IT is getting it to provide what people want, when they need it – but in order to do that, you must have knowledge. Knowledge of the customer experience, knowledge of the way the work gets through the organisation and knowledge of the environment in which it all functions. Without understanding the whole – IT will only ever be a point solution that will lock-in bad practices, drain organisations of funds and help deliver poor service.
It’s sad really – it all looked so promising in the 70’s and 80’s !
Oh yes, well said!!!
Next week I’ll have a talk with a Super Collegue (C-Level, Business side) and my goal is to pass him that new way of thinking (systems thinking) about IT and whole corporation as a new dimension of analysis.
You make a point that is hardly ever made in business. Technology is about taking a process from one point to another at the speed of light, yet if people are not configured around the technology with the same skill, the process may be slower. Time to market applied to tams is the low hanging fruit for revolutionizing teams and business today.
[…] Porque todos detestam o Departamento TI Imagem original: http://blog.newsystemsthinking.com/dismantling-the-information-technology-monoliths/ […]